The Game-Changing Impact That Self-Talk Has on Athlete Performance
- Taylor Cook
- 5 days ago
- 4 min read
If you’ve ever competed at a high level, you already know this: the real battles don’t only happen on the ice, the field, or the court. They happen in your head. The impact that self-talk has on athlete performance is one of the most underrated forces in sports — and yet it influences everything from confidence to reaction time to resilience after mistakes.
As someone who’s played professional hockey and now coaches athletes on mental performance, I’ve seen how much an athlete’s inner voice can either elevate them or quietly destroy their momentum. And the truth is, most athletes underestimate how much that internal dialogue is steering their game long before the game ever starts.
Self-talk isn’t just a nice-to-have mental skill. It’s an engine that’s always running, whether you’re aware of it or not.
Self-Talk: The Quiet Narrator Shaping Every Play
Every athlete, no matter their level, has a constant mental commentary running in the background. Sometimes it’s deliberate — like talking yourself through a routine, giving yourself cues, or reminding yourself to stay composed. But most of the time, it’s automatic. It happens fast, emotionally, and without permission.
And that’s where things get interesting.
Your mind is always checking in:
“You’re ready.”
“Don’t mess up.”
“Why am I like this?”
“You’ve got this.”
“Everyone saw that mistake.”
“Reset and move.”
Those lines don’t just float by. They shape your emotional state, the decisions you make, and how quickly you bounce back when things go sideways.
Athletes like to think they’re driven by skill, preparation, and toughness. But in reality, they’re driven by the stories they tell themselves between every play.
Why Negative Self-Talk Feels So Natural
High performers are wired to analyze and critique. They want to grow. They want to fix mistakes. But that same intensity often turns inward. Instead of evaluating performance, they evaluate themselves.
And suddenly the voice that was supposed to help starts to hurt.
“Why can’t I do this?”
“I’m blowing it.”
“I always screw that up.”
It’s not the mistake that hurts performance — it’s the spiral that follows.
I’ve seen elite athletes completely tank their confidence after a single error, not because they lacked ability, but because their inner voice became the opponent.
The Real Impact That Self-Talk Has on Athlete Performance
Here’s what I wish every athlete understood: performance is emotional. And emotions are created by thoughts.
That means your self-talk isn’t just background noise. It directly influences your:
• recovery time after mistakes
• composure under pressure
• creativity and decision-making
• confidence
• reaction speed
• sense of control
• consistency
When your thoughts stay clean, present, and supportive, your body can play freely. But when the mind gets crowded with fear, self-judgment, or pressure, everything tightens. You hesitate. You overthink. You force plays. You play small.
This isn’t theoretical — it’s neurological. The brain performs differently when it feels safe versus when it feels threatened, even if the “threat” is your own words.
A Lesson From My Time as a Pro Goalie
As a goalie, you don’t get the luxury of hiding. Every mistake is visible. Every bounce matters. The real battle happens in the space between your ears — that 15 centimeters of mental real estate that decides whether you stay composed or spiral.
I had games early in my career where one bad goal would send me into a spiral. My self-talk became punishment. I wasn’t playing the puck anymore — I was playing against my own mind. The difference between my good games and my bad games had nothing to do with talent and everything to do with language.
Later in my career, I learned the power of simple, grounding phrases like:
“Next shot.”
“Square up.”
“Breathe.”
Clear, actionable, calming instructions.
That kind of self-talk kept me in the moment, not stuck on what happened five seconds ago.
That’s when I stopped trying to control the game and started controlling my focus.
Positive Self-Talk Isn’t About Being Unrealistic — It’s About Being Useful
A common mistake I see in athletes is trying to replace negative thoughts with over-the-top positivity. That doesn’t work, because the brain can smell fake confidence a mile away.
Useful self-talk is:
short
believable
actionable
repeatable
grounding
Instead of: “I’m the best player here!”
Try: “Stay composed.”
Instead of: “Don’t screw this up.”
Try: “One play at a time.”
Self-talk is less about hype and more about direction.
How Athletes Can Improve Their Self-Talk Today
Here are a few simple tools I teach athletes at every level:
The 5-Second Reset
After a mistake, choose a phrase (like “clear it,” “reset,” or “next rep”) and pair it with one deep breath.
Focus Anchors
Pick a cue word that brings you back to the present — “here,” “now,” or “trust.”
Post-Game Language Review
After every game, write down the phrases that helped you and the ones that hurt you. You’ll start to see patterns.
Identity-Based Language
Shift “I am messing up” to “I felt off today.”
Identity stays strong. Emotion remains temporary.
Small changes to your internal language create massive shifts in your performance.
The impact that self-talk has on athlete performance is one of the most powerful levers any athlete can pull. You can train harder, get stronger, and build better technique — but if your inner voice is working against you, you’ll never play at your true potential.
The good news? Self-talk is a skill that can be trained and strengthened, like any other. It can become the competitive advantage most athletes never unlock.
Control your words, and you control your game.
If reading this makes you think, “Yeah… this might be the missing piece for me,” then let’s talk.
No pressure. No commitment. Just a conversation about where you’re at and how I might be able to help you dial in the mental side of your game.
Comments